Astrophotography is a fascinating hobby that allows us to capture the beauty and wonder of the night sky. However, it is also a challenging one that requires a lot of skill, patience, and knowledge. One of the most important concepts that every astrophotographer should understand is SNR or signal-to-noise ratio. In this blog post, I explain what SNR is, what affects it, and how to measure it. I will also include some tips on how to improve your SNR and get better astrophotography images.
What is SNR?
SNR stands for signal-to-noise ratio, and it is a measure of how much useful information (signal) is present in an image compared to the unwanted variations (noise). Signal is the light that comes from the object you are photographing, such as a star, a galaxy, or a nebula. Noise is anything that interferes with the signal, such as random fluctuations in the sensor, thermal effects, atmospheric turbulence, light pollution, or cosmic rays.
The higher the SNR, the better the image quality. A high SNR image will have more details, contrast, and colour fidelity than a low SNR image. A low SNR image will look grainy, blurry, or washed out.
What affects SNR?
Many factors affect the SNR of an astrophotography image. Some of them are:
Exposure time
The longer you expose your sensor to light, the more signal you will collect. However, you will also collect more noise, especially from thermal effects and dark current. There is an optimal exposure time that maximizes the SNR for a given object and camera.
Aperture
The larger the aperture of your lens or telescope, the more light you will gather per unit of time. This will increase your signal and improve your SNR. However, larger apertures also have drawbacks, such as higher cost, weight, and complexity.
ISO or gain
The ISO or gain setting of your camera controls how much the signal is amplified before being converted to digital data by the ADC (analogue-to-digital converter). Higher ISO or gain will increase your signal but also your noise, especially from read noise. There is an optimal ISO or gain setting that maximizes the SNR for a given camera and exposure time.
Number of frames
One way to improve your SNR is to take multiple frames of the same object and combine them using a process called stacking or integration. Stacking reduces the noise by averaging out the random variations across different frames while preserving the signal. The more frames you stack, the higher your SNR will be. However, stacking also requires more storage space, processing time, and alignment accuracy.
Calibration frames
Another way to improve your SNR is to use calibration frames to correct for some sources of noise in your images. Calibration frames are images taken with specific conditions to capture the noise patterns of your camera and telescope. There are three main types of calibration frames: dark frames (taken with no light reaching the sensor), bias frames (taken with zero exposure time), and flat frames (taken with a uniform light source). By subtracting these frames from your light frames (the images of your object), you can reduce the noise from dark current, read noise, and vignetting respectively.
How to measure SNR?
There are different ways to measure the SNR of an astrophotography image. One simple method is to use a software tool that can calculate the mean and standard deviation of pixel values in a region of interest (ROI). The mean represents the signal level and the standard deviation represents the noise level. The ratio of these two values gives you an estimate of the SNR.
For example, using ImageJ, you can select a ROI that contains only sky background and use Analyze > Measure to get the mean and standard deviation values. Then you can select another ROI that contains a star or an object and repeat the same process. The ratio of these two means will give you an estimate of the SNR for that star or object.
Another method is to use a formula that takes into account various sources of noise in your image.
The formula is:
$$SNR = S / \sqrt{(S/G) + N\sigma^2 * (1+1/M)}$$
Where S is the star count, sigma is the sky standard deviation, N is the number of pixels in the star aperture, and M is
the number of pixels in the sky annulus and G is the camera gain (ADUs/photon).
This formula is more accurate than the simple mean ratio method, but it requires more information about your camera and your image.
How to improve SNR?
There are several ways to improve your SNR and get better images of your celestial targets. Here are some tips:
Choose a suitable target
Some objects are brighter and easier to photograph than others. For example, the Moon and the planets have a high SNR because they are very bright and reflect a lot of sunlight. On the other hand, faint nebulae and galaxies have a low SNR because they emit very little light and are often obscured by dust and gas. You should choose a target that matches your equipment and skill level, and that has a high enough SNR to show some details and colours.
Use a tracking mount
One of the biggest challenges of astrophotography is to keep your camera aligned with the moving sky. If you use a fixed tripod, you will have to limit your exposure time to avoid star trails, which will reduce your signal. If you use a tracking mount, you can take longer exposures and collect more signal without blurring the stars. A tracking mount can be either manual or motorised and can be either equatorial or alt-azimuthal. The most accurate and stable type is an equatorial mount with a motor drive and a guide scope or camera.
Use a low-noise camera
Not all cameras are created equal when it comes to noise performance. Some cameras have lower read noise, dark current, and thermal noise than others. These cameras will produce cleaner images with higher SNR. Generally speaking, dedicated astro-cameras have better noise performance than consumer DSLRs or mirrorless cameras, because they are designed specifically for astrophotography. They also have features such as cooling systems, monochrome sensors, and higher bit depth that can further improve the SNR. However, they are also more expensive and require additional accessories such as power supplies, filters, and software.
Use optimal settings
Depending on your camera and your target, you should adjust your settings to achieve the best SNR possible. This includes choosing the right exposure time, ISO or gain, aperture, and focus. You should also use a histogram or a live view to check your exposure level and avoid overexposing or underexposing your image. A good rule of thumb is to aim for an exposure level that fills about half of the histogram range without clipping the highlights or shadows.
Stack multiple frames
As we mentioned before, stacking multiple frames of the same object can significantly improve your SNR by averaging out the noise across different frames while preserving the signal. To stack your frames effectively, you should use a software tool that can align, calibrate, register, and integrate your images. There are many software options available for this purpose, such as DeepSkyStacker, PixInsight, or Astro Pixel Processor. You should also use calibration frames (dark, bias, and flat) to correct for some sources of noise in your images before stacking them.
Dither between frames
Another technique that can improve your SNR when stacking multiple frames is dithering. Dithering is a process of slightly shifting your camera position between frames using small random movements. This helps to break up any fixed pattern noise or bad pixels that may be present in your sensor or telescope optics. By dithering between frames, you can reduce these artefacts and smooth out the background noise in your final stacked image.
SNR is a key concept in astrophotography that affects the quality of your images. By understanding what SNR is, what affects it, and how to measure it, you can optimize your settings and techniques to achieve the best results possible. Remember that SNR is not the only thing that matters in astrophotography, but it is a good indicator of how well you are capturing the beauty of the night sky.
Please note that this is not professional or expert advice, but only a general introduction to the topic.
Sources:
Comments